| Reviews:
Judges'
Comments - NSW Premier’s Literary Award 1996
"An outstanding contribution to Australian
literature."
Australian
Book Review
"Caravanserai
challenged my views of Islam; it is an interesting,
beautifully written and emotional account of one
person’s journey."
Moira Raynor - Writer,
lawyer, speaker and human rights activist
"…a powerful reminder of what the Australian
‘national character’ truly is, and a stronger
argument that the toleration of prejudice and
maltreatment of migrants, asylum-seekers, Muslims and
persons of Middle eastern appearance’ today is
profoundly undermining
Australia
’s maturity as a sovereign nation."
Katy Nebhan - The Australian Public
Intellectual Network:
" ....The reader soon discovers that the
orientalist exoticisation of the east is used by Deen,
somewhat cheekily, to play on western stereotypes in
order to subvert, challenge and question them in a way
that is both humorous and informative..."
Full
Review
Irfan
Yusuf, The Week,
June 2009
"This
seminal book includes entertaining profiles of some of
Australia’s oldest Muslim families. It provides
an excellent response to cultural warriors who allege
Muslim migrants arrived as one monolithic troublesome
wave."
Full
Review
Katy
Nebhan, Culture Matters, August 2007
"….
Maybe it’s time to put all Harry Potter books aside,
and to give this book a try. And especially if you’re
from a European-Christian background, whether you have
prejudices against Muslims or not, please read this book
because Hanifa Deen is basically saying Muslims are
neither wonderful nor terrible, but they are only human
beings like everybody else."
Sussan Khadem, Overland 174, Autumn 2004
"Deen has a gift for telling stories in a
poetic and descriptive way. [Her book] is an important contribution to
literature and should be read not as an attempt to consume the Other but as a
window into a part of Australia
which makes the country what it is today." Graham
Williams, Sydney Morning Herald, Spectrum 7 June
2003
"….
She writes with deep anger but dignified calm. Read her
and weep for the country we have become, urged on by
politicians at the highest levels, and their shock-jock
accomplices. If you have ever doubted the urgent need to
reverse this downward spiral, this elegant and beautiful
book will persuade you."
Australian
Book Review June/July 2003
"….Deen, a high profile human rights activist and
social commentator, writes in an accessible and personal
style to comment on the current state of affairs that
sees many Muslims afraid and feeling unsafe in our
communities. Refusing to relinquish a belief in the
“intrinsic fairness” of our national character, this
is a plea for new creative alliances among
Australians."
The
Age Saturday 28 June 2003
"When
this was first published in 1994 (to great critical
acclaim) it was a much-needed introduction to the
history of Muslims in
Australia
. Since then, in the wake of September 11 and the
Tampa
disgrace, Muslims have become the new “other” (both
domestically and internationally) and this updated
version is even more needed. … But it’s not simply a
timely text; it’s thematically complex, yet simply and
evocatively written, the title linking journeys ancient
and modern—with some fascinating descriptions of the
old caravanserais."
|